Digital thread: automate workflows without losing engineering judgement

Stefan Keller

By
Stefan Keller
Expert, Wind Energy

5 minute read

A structural calculation on a modern wind turbine draws on inputs that all must agree with each other: the 3D geometry, the loads a specific controller version produces, boundary conditions to neighbouring systems, material properties and so on.

 

In most engineering organizations, these still live in separate systems, updated on separate timelines, thus requiring manual version control between inputs. Such manual processes slow down the design process and the can lead to errors.

»
When a component fails in the field, instantaneous access to reliable data is fundamental to limit the consequences.

Where manual workflows gets costly

Inefficient design processes are one thing, but the consequences of errors in data might be much bigger and reveal themselves only after years of operation, in the worst case through premature failure of components, leading to very costly repair or replacement campaigns. When a component fails in the field, instantaneous access to reliable data is fundamental to limit the consequences. Unreliable information on spare parts and repair procedures can quickly lead to increased downtime and a root cause analysis based on the wrong data can lead to repeated failures, impacting large fleets, and potentially to warranty claims.

What a digital thread does

 

The risks related to manual workflows have nothing to do with hard engineering skills. They derive from the use of many different systems throughout the life cycle of a complex product.

 

As an answer to these risks, a digital thread connects requirements, design, materials, manufacturing, and field data into one traceable thread. At every step, the engineer working from it is working with the right and traceable data.

 

CREADIS has built this for two of the world’s leading wind turbine manufacturers, for drivetrain design and for electrical modelling. In one case, the thread connects the full engineering workflow, from geometry, loads and material data to structural analysis and links the data to a precise production model. In another, it automatically builds and validates the electrical models required for commercial wind farm projects, as well as for new products. These digital threads automate workflows and processes that require data from a variety of sources, eliminating data handling and versioning errors and reducing the strain on the engineering organization.

 

The digital threads CREADIS develops together with our partners never replace engineering judgement. They remove the manual work around it, so that time goes into evaluating and validating results instead of cross-checking databases and chasing around the organisation for the accurate numbers. That is where investing in digital threads pays off.

 

A digital thread can be enhanced with embedded digital verification, which can significantly reduce the costs of product development. A properly designed and implemented digital thread has the capability to also digitalize validation activities and thus remove cost without cutting corners.

Deliver real value into the organisation

 

Done right, a digital thread has immense potential to improve the economics of OEMs. It’s many applications across the product life cycle offer significant optimization potential from engineering to field operations, showing up on the bottom line. Time and resources can be dedicated to more valuable work than data chasing, design errors and fleet issues can be avoided, and field operations become more efficient.

It does require taking on a digital transformation of at least parts of the engineering workflows, but with the right partner, we have shown that it is perfectly feasible.

We witness first hand that the organizations getting the most from digital transformation are those who can identify the workflows where errors are most expensive. A digital thread can initially be built around these workflows, before expanding into other areas. We believe that digital threads are a significant opportunity for OEMs wanting to seriously tackle cost of poor quality across the product life cycle and increase the return from their R&D investments.

Facts

»

what the data shows

McKinsey research on digital twins in product development found total development time cut by 20 to 50 percent for some users, with products that start out as digital twins showing 25 percent fewer quality issues once they reach production; some companies cut the number of physical prototypes needed from two or three down to one. Siemens Energy’s 2023 disclosure that quality issues on its onshore turbine platforms would cost around €2.2 billion to fix, with remediation running for years, shows what a mismatch can cost once it reaches the field at scale. Gearbox bearing failure research from the US Department of Energy and NREL points to the same root cause: small inconsistencies between design assumptions and what actually gets built or operated. 

Background data: (figures are reported results from specific companies, not industry-wide averages); Siemens Energy, press release on remediation charges at Siemens Gamesa, 7–8 August 2023; US Department of Energy / NREL, wind turbine gearbox bearing failure research (white-etch cracking), Wind Energy Technologies Office.

CASES & INSIGHTS

Engineering expertise in practice

Explore real-world cases and expert perspectives on the engineering challenges shaping performance, reliability and profitability across renewable energy.

How can we help you?

Are you interested in learning more about DIS/CREADIS?
Enter your information in the form and we will contact you shortly.